Sugar and Spice Retail Store Order Menu

sands-delivery-map.jpgOrder cakes or larger quantities of our bakery items to share with friends or for a special occasion. Pick up your order at our store in the Indiana Memorial Union or request delivery on campus for $5 per order, or within 5 miles of campus for $10 per order.

Breakfast Pastries

Priced by the dozen, unless otherwise noted.

  • Assorted Muffins—$18
  • Assorted Danish*—$20
  • Banana Bread served with Butter (12 servings)—$18 per loaf
  • Blueberry Scones—$18
  • Buttermilk Biscuits with Butter and Jelly—$22
  • Cinnamon Rolls—$26
  • Cinnamon Sugar Pecan Coffee Cake* (12 servings)—$18 per loaf
  • Croissants (Plain or Chocolate)—$24
  • Almond Croissants*—$26

* Items contain nuts. Ask your sales associate for allergen and nutritional information.


Priced by the dozen, unless otherwise noted.

  • Chocolate No Bakes Cookies—mini bites $16; regular $22
  • Chocolate Chunk Cookies—$25
  • Chocolate Chunk Cookie Cake—$25 per cake
  • Gingerbread People—mini bites $16; regular $25; jumbo $25
  • Iced Sugar Mini Bites*—$18
  • Iced Sugar Tridents Cookies—$28
  • Iced Sugar Cookie Cake*—$25 per cake
  • Monster Cake—$25 per cake
  • Sprinkled Sugar Cookies—$22
  • Rice Krispie Treats—mini bites $16; regular $22
  • Special K Chewies—mini bites $16; regular $22

* Custom icing will incur additional costs


  • 9” Round Cake with 2 layers (16 servings) $25 each
  • Single Layer Cakes
    • Quarter sheet (24 servings) $25 each
    • Half sheet (48 servings) $40 each
    • Full sheet (96 servings) $57 each

The Wells Cake

Our signature cake, named for IU President Herman B Wells, features a delicious filling of fresh strawberries and bananas. Half sheet $70 each



$3 each

  • Cake flavors: Carrot, Chocolate, Cream & Crimson, Red Velvet, and Vanilla
  • Icing flavors: Chocolate Buttercream, Cream Cheese, and Vanilla Buttercream

Additional premier flavors, and gluten free or vegan options are available upon request. Please discuss the possibilities with your sales associate.